Krysti

To begin with, you need a larger source picture so we can see your work.

Needed to take out some of the shadow from the arm as the shadow cast wouldn't be so much from just the sleeve. Also, would have rated you higher had you left in the ball and glove. You left in the shadow from the arm and glove, if taking the arm and glove, the shadow should have been cloned out as well.

Well done!

I like that you added a tag in the shirt, but the front of the collar looks very flat. Needs a bit of shadow to add some depth.

The right side of the collar needs a bit more work, but overall a nice chop.

Very confusing, should have posted your source picture.

Need a larger source picture and the collar doesn't look right. Too flat and jagged.

lol, good one!

Nice job!

I would have liked to have seen your source image, but from what I can see, the chop is very jagged. Need to work on your masking. Use a small brush. Not sure but it looks as if you might have used a selection tool instead of masking.

I would have rated this higher had you left the people in the background.

The tree on the far left doesn't look right nor the space between the two statues on the right where the hand from the middle statue was... it looks really smudged.

The fireworks are really cool, but the black in the sky doesn't match and really takes away from all the work you did on the fireworks.

Need to continue to work on your masking.

Well done!

This would have been a nice entry... but, it looks like the stove is on the outside... the tree reflection looks as if the actual tree is behind the stove. What I can see of the stove, looks very flat. You really need to post your sources to help in an image this confusing. It also looks as if the stove is sitting on a floor that is tilted making your perspective look weird.

This is cute, but the shadow and light throw this off for me. The knight appears to be standing behind the railing where the light has stopped, yet he has light hitting him. If the sun was indeed hitting him, the sun would need to be hitting the dog and there would need to be shadow from the dog and knight as well. What would have solved this, would have been to bring the night out into the sunlight.

Nice idea, but why did you stop with your stove pipe. You should have cloned in or replaced the pipe to extend to the ceiling to give this a "real" feeling.

This is really cool. You really have a great concept here. Need to work on your masking and shadows. The image is very flat.

This is a really great concept, but is too pixelated for me. The reflection from the fire also seems a bit to blunt. I think reflections from a fire would be have random edging.

The stove looks as if it is about to slip off the stones...

Nice job, great entry!

wow, great entry! Very creative.

Really would have liked to have seen more done with the themepost, but the room is nice.

This is really neat.