Six professional looking men mill about a conference room, making their way to their seats. Chairman Rawlings stands up at the head of the table…
Chairman Rawlings: Good morning ladies and gentlemen, it’s time to call this meeting to order. We have some important business to attend to today. Let’s not waste any time.
They find their seats and sit down.
Pierce: The first item on the agenda today is declaring an official winner in the ‘America’s Favorite Mitten-Shaped State Contest’. What are the nominations?
Lindsey: I will read the list of nominations in its entirety. After the list has been read, the floor will be opened to discussion on any of the nominees. The nominations are, in no particular order: Maine, Wisconsin, Michigan, and South Carolina. The floor is now open to discussion.
Oscars: I can’t believe we’re even voting on this. It should be plain to see that South Carolina is the clear winner.
Miller: South Carolina? South Carolina looks nothing like a mitten!
Oscars: Of course it does! Any fool can see that!
Miller: No it doesn’t! It’s just a blob on the map that doesn’t look like anything!
Rawlings: I think he’s right, Oscars. I think you’re letting the fact that you’re from South Carolina affect your judgement.
Oscars: You’re just jealous because -–
Donnell: If I may interject, let’s discuss Michigan. In my opinion, it is much more like a mitten than any other state.
Pierce: I have to agree.
Lindsey and Rawlings nod in agreement.
Miller: I can see where you get that, but what’s the deal with that pointy northern part of Michigan?
Lindsey: Pointy northern part?
Miller: Yeah, that, what’s it called, Upper Peninsula?
Rawlings: There’s no ‘Upper Peninsula’ to Michigan.
Oscars: Oh, that top part, I always thought it was part of Wisconsin.
Rawlings: It is.
Miller: No, it’s not! Look at the map – it’s all labeled as Michigan. See (points to map on the wall) – it’s all the same purple color.
Donnell: It was obviously a mistake.
Pierce: Well, I say it’s not part of the state, and that makes it five to one, leaving a very much mitten-like state.
Miller: You can’t just vote that the Upper Peninsula is not part of Michigan! It’s part of the state and we can’t change that!
Oscars: Shut up, Miller, you’ve been outvoted.
Miller mumbles something about being surrounded by idiots under his breath and shakes his head in disgust.
Rawlings: What about Maine and Wisconsin?
Lindsey: Well, Wisconsin has what I would call a ‘severe lack of thumb’. I can’t even consider it.
Pierce: Yeah, a lack of thumb makes it impossible for me to vote that way, either.
Donnell: Maine, on the other hand, kinda has a thumb-like thingy, but it’s not as well defined. It’s kinda like a webbed-semi-thumb-thingy.
Oscars: Yeah, you could argue that Maine has a thumb, but even if you did, the ‘hand’ part of the state is way too thin. There’s only room for like 2 fingers. Not that I’m prejudice against two fingered people, but a 2-fingered mitten doesn’t really represent the common understanding of a mitten.
Rawlings: Point well made.
Oscars: I still think South Carolina looks like a mitten.
Pierce: And you’re certainly entitled to your stupid opinion, but it’s not going to win.
Silence for several seconds.
Rawlings: Are we ready to vote?
Everyone nods in agreement.
Rawlings: All those in favor of Maine, say "aye".
Miller: Aye.
Rawlings: All those in favor of Wisconsin, say "aye".
No votes.
Rawlings: All those in favor of Michigan, say "aye".
Donnell, Pierce, and Lindsey: Aye.
Rawlings: That’s a majority. Michigan is now America’s Favorite Mitten Shaped State.
Oscars: What about South Carolina?
Pierce: Shut up, Oscars.
Rawlings: Now for the next item on the agenda. America’s best panhandle…